“It is not possible to immediately have 50% of the seats for women”, Supreme Court on NDA seat reservation petition

-



06 March, 2023

On 3rd March 2023, the Supreme Court of India was hearing a petition seeking 50 % reservation in the National Defence Academy (NDA) for women. The bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Sanjay Kishan Kaul rejected the plea stating, “it is not possible to immediately have 50% of the seats for women.” The top Court judges also highlighted that they were already addressing the case in a batch of petitions and all relevant issues were monitored for providing the best for the women candidates. The petition was filed by a former female NDA aspirant who did not obtain the requisite merit in the women's category though in overall merit she would have more marks than some of the men candidates who would be admitted. The bench also stated that “...though we have sympathy for the petitioner, in the present scenario it is not possible for us to give any relief.” 

Earlier, in August 2021, the centre argued that restriction against women was a matter of policy whereas the bench headed by Justice Kaul rejected the made argument and allowed women to take the NDA examination. Further in September 2021, the top Court dismissed the plea filed by the Defence Ministry seeking a delay in the induction of women into the NDA. The bench then stated that “It would be difficult for us to accept such a petition, the aspirations of the women candidates have arisen in view of the orders we had passed. The Armed Services of India have dealt with very difficult situations on the border and in the country and acquitted themselves admirably. To deal with emergencies is a part of their training. We are sure that training would come in handy to deal with this ‘emergency’ if it is so perceived for the larger gender-neutral issues which cannot be postponed.”

The Supreme Court also highlighted a case ‘Kush Kalra v. Union of India & Ors.’ where various other larger questions were unanswered in association with seat reservation for women. While hearing the matter on March 3, 2023, the bench agreed to list the case with other similar petitions stating “the listing of this petition with aforementioned matter would only give an opportunity to the petitioner to assist the Court. List along with the other writ petitions.”

Also Read: Legal Articles

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Alibi and Witness: Key Differences

-
Image
Introduction The criminal justice system is a complex web of procedures, laws, and principles designed to ensure fairness, justice, and protection of innocents. Central to this system are two crucial elements: alibis and witnesses. Both play pivotal roles in the process of establishing facts and determining guilt or innocence, but they serve distinct functions. In this article, we delve into the  key differences between an alibi and a witness , exploring their roles, significance, and impact in legal proceedings. Part I: Alibi — The Defense’s Shield An alibi is a powerful legal defense strategy employed in criminal trials. At its core, it aims to provide evidence that the defendant was not present at the scene of the crime when it occurred. The term ‘Alibi’, as it is, is neither defined in the Indian Penal Code nor the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. It was recognized as a Rule of evidence under Section 11 of the Indian Evidence Act. Along with this,  Section 103  of the India...
Read more

Equal Remuneration Act, 1976

-
Image
  Introduction The  Equal Remuneration Act, 1976  is an important legislation in India that prohibits discrimination in terms of remuneration on the grounds of gender. It means the Act ensures equal pay for men and women for the same or similar work. The Equal Remuneration Act of 1976 was enacted by the Indian Parliament on February 11, 1976, with an aim “to provide for the payment of equal remuneration to men and women workers and for the prevention of discrimination, on the ground of sex, against women in the matter in the matter of employment and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.” It extends to the whole of India including all establishments either public or private sectors (employing ten or more persons). By promoting gender equality in remuneration, the act seeks to establish fair and just working conditions for all employees, regardless of their gender. Also, it prohibits discrimination made by employers against women in matters of recruitment, ...
Read more

Domestic Violence Act, 2005

-
Image
  Introduction:  Domestic Violence Act, 2005 In societies worldwide, domestic violence stands as an issue that casts a shadow over the well-being of individuals and the progress of communities. It can be defined as a pattern of ‘abusive behavior within intimate relationships’. Our constitution serves as a guardian, protecting our individual rights. Beyond individual suffering, the societal impact of domestic violence undermines the foundations of a healthy and thriving community. This article delves into the legal provisions in India aimed at combating domestic violence, shedding light on the rights of victims and the responsibilities of law enforcement agencies. What is Domestic Violence? Domestic violence refers to one person seeking to gain power and control over another through physical, emotional, sexual, verbal, or economic means. It is a form of violence that occurs within the context of a domestic setting, such as a marital or cohabiting relationship. Domestic violence...
Read more